Session 7:

Understanding ourselves - Part one

Session overview

This session builds on the work of the previous growth mindset session by helping children identify and tame the voice of their inner critics. The inner critic is an internal psychological construct that undermines personal confidence and the willingness to face new challenges. It hampers children's ability to aspire to greater levels of achievement and step outside their comfort zones. It actively impairs performance when children do well and when they don't. 

Psychologists see the inner critic as a pattern of destructive thoughts towards ourselves (and sometimes others) that manifest as nagging voices or beliefs in our heads. It is not an auditory hallucination but a well-integrated stream of consciousness at the root of much self-loathing or harmful behaviour. It can be seen as 'the enemy within'. Strong inner critical voices have been connected with several mental health issues. It can affect every aspect of life, including our self-esteem, confidence, relationships, and accomplishments. The inner critic erodes our positive feelings about ourselves, amplifying self-criticism, self-denial and inwardness. It causes us to distance ourselves from achieving our goals and has even been linked to addiction.

There is a difference between an inner critic and a conscience, though people sometimes confuse the two. An inner critic is not there to encourage or guide positively. It often degrades and punishes, making feelings of self-loathing more likely, leading to destructive or undesirable behaviour. However, we can tame the inner critic, turning it into an inner friend, which first involves identifying and understanding the nature of its power. Following this, an alternative internal dialogue can be developed – one of the inner friend. This process is carried out via discussion around the true nature of friendship —particularly when our friends make mistakes— and a guided visualisation exercise where the inner friend asks the inner critic to step aside.

The story of Kwan (and specifically the characters of Hannah and Samira) provides a helpful metaphor for the critic and the friend, respectively. Session Seven builds on these concepts and incorporates the learning from previous sessions to help pupils create an ideal inner friend —a helpful 'co-pilot' that not only guides them in achieving success but also helps them to deal with the challenges and obstacles of change and transition.

A. Session aims & objectives

B. Learning outcomes

C. Terminology introduced

Example definitions of key terminology are included but, wherever possible, use pupils' agreed descriptions, as per previous sessions. 

CRITIC—a person who expresses an unfavourable opinion of someone/something

INNER CRITIC—a voice inside our head that attacks us, suggesting we are imperfect, wrong, inadequate, worthless, guilty, etc.

INNER FRIEND—positive self-talk using the perspective of how we should talk to friends to quieten the inner critic's voice and improve our sense of self.

D. Resources required

❏ Kwan's story comic

❏ Slide pack for Session Seven
(note: some activity slides are blank for you to make use of as you wish)

❏ Resource Sheet 7a: Inner critic vs inner friend (x2 copies per pupil)

Starter activity: The story so far

As previous sessions have shown, when good people make choices that result in us being poorly treated or unscrupulous people attempt to influence us to do something we don't want to do, it can be challenging to react positively. Kwan, Ella and events in the story have shown how easy it can be to make poor decisions that result in consequences we would never choose or want. The only way to ensure we always make our own, positive choices is to understand who we are and listen to what we genuinely believe to be correct. We all have that little voice inside our heads, but it needs to be trained to help rather than hinder.

The programme's second part focuses on building and planning for transition. Pupils will apply a positive growth mindset and set themselves goals for the next year based on this mindset, and a vital part of this is to create a positive narrative within their own thinking

Recap and review ground rules as a class. 

Discuss any rules that worked well and any that didn't work – do they need to change? Make amendments if required. Ensure pupils are clear about why ground rules are used and why they are so important.

EXPLAIN:

Let's re-familiarise ourselves with the story, the characters, and the key activities we have already completed. We'll begin by reminding ourselves what has happened in the story so far.

Read Kwan's story to the fourth checkpoint.

For pupils using iPads: the story will stop at the appropriate point and ask for checkpoint 4 password (dilemma)

For pupils using non-iPad devices: the story will stop at the end of Episode 4


Activity one: Inner critic 

This activity aims to help children identify the voice of their inner critic. It can be intimidating to speak our internal thoughts out loud, so a gentle way to begin is by looking at the story's characters. Providing a proxy for pupils to explore these ideas offers them a safe environment to reflect on their own thoughts and feelings. 

EXPLAIN:

Sometimes a little voice inside our head says things that we would never say to others. We might describe this as an inner critic, and we will consider the impact this could have on us. 

Take another look at the scene where Ella and her friends are laughing. 

ASK: 

EXPLAIN:

In the final panel of this page, it may not be people saying all of these things to Kwan. Some comments may be his inner critic talking.

ASK:

Collect pupils' responses (display them on the smart board) and debate whether they are helpful and inspiring, or mean and deflating. Move the discussion to the children's experiences by asking if they have heard their inner critics saying anything similar. Alternatively, if there is time, identify other moments in the story when an inner critic might have controlled a character's actions. 

ASK:

Activity two: Inner friend

Developing the inner friend's voice means tuning into different thoughts or an alternative narrative (sometimes called a counter-narrative). Again, this can initially be difficult for children to do concerning themselves, so it can often be easier to start by thinking about the kinder and more supportive thoughts they might use about others. 

In this activity, pupils will start to redefine the thoughts they choose to have using the distancing technique of 'the perspective of a friend' or perhaps even a character (e.g. Samira) from the story. Later in the session, they will be encouraged to adopt this same perspective of a friend when dealing with their own thoughts to apply a kinder, more supportive approach to themselves.

SHOW:

Slide 9: Activity 2 — Inner friend

Slide 10: Inner friend 

In small groups or pairs, have pupils identify what they would say to a friend who was worried about achieving a goal or had made a mistake. 

ASK:


Bring the discussion back to the whole group and see what responses pupils have created

ASK:

Hand out Resource Sheet 7a: Inner critic vs inner friend

As a class, review the scene where Hannah suggests that Kwan should 'set Ella up'. Use this conversation as a metaphor for the inner critic. Therefore, pupils should imagine the conversation happening in Kwan's head with his inner critic. 

Discuss the critical phrases and how pupils think these might make Kwan feel or why his inner critic might be saying them.

Next, in pairs, read to the fifth checkpoint (which finishes on the interactive text messaging sequence between Ella and 'Logan' (Kwan)). 

For pupils using iPads: the story will stop at the appropriate point and ask for checkpoint 5 password (choice)

For pupils using non-iPad devices: the story will stop at the end of Episode 5

Using Resource Sheet 7a: Inner critic vs inner friend, pupils should note what thoughts might be going through Ella's head.

ASK:

In pairs, pupils should read to the end of the story on page 36.

Imagining Samira to be the voice of Kwan's inner friend, review the scene and use a fresh copy of Resource Sheet 7a: Inner critic vs inner friend to record examples of phrases that represent Kwan's inner critic or inner friend.

Plenary / Homework: Three good things

When looking at concepts such as the negative self-image that results from our inner critical thoughts, it's essential to balance this with strategies that help shape positive thinking. This final activity sets up a simple exercise for pupils to complete over the next few weeks to help them focus on the positive things in their lives.

EXPLAIN:

Today we've looked at the idea that we all have a little voice inside our heads. This voice can play a positive or a negative role in our lives; therefore, we need to train it to ensure it doesn't sabotage our thinking.

Next time we'll look at the inner critic and inner voice again and develop some strategies to frame what our inner thoughts tell us. Try to be more aware of those thoughts and consider your actions and any consequences. This process will help you continue to make good choices.

Between now and then, at the end of each day, note three positive things for which you are grateful. These can be small, such as: 'I answered a question in class and I don't usually put my hand up', or big: 'I got a top grade for my last piece of work'.

Against each positive event, write:


Complete these ready for Session Eight next time. It might also be valuable to work through less favourable events, in the same way, using the same process to make sense and understand if they result from critical thoughts.

SHOW

Slide 13: Learning outcomes for Session Seven

Recap the key learning outcomes in the light of today's discussions

Delivery resources

Lime 2021-22 Y6 S7 Checklist.pdf

Checklist 

Lime 2021-22 Y6 S7 Resource Sheet(s).pdf

Resources sheet(s)

Lime 2021-22 Y6 S7 Slides (PDF Version).pdf

Slides (PDF)

Lime 2021-22 Y6 S7 Slides (PowerPoint Version).pptx

Slides (PowerPoint)

For iPad Kwan's story app users

Check point 1 password: identity

Check point 2 password: influence

Check point 3 password: need

Check point 4 password: dilemma

Check point 5 password: choice

For non-iPad Kwan's story users

Access code: T7CmY